Wednesday, March 1, 2023

Rent-stabilized Harlem tenants sue after "Frankensteining"

 The Gothamist: "Rent-stabilized Harlem tenants sue after 'Frankenstein" renovations carve up apartments."

EXCERPT:

Tenants in two Harlem buildings are joining a lawsuit to stop what they, along with other renters in Brooklyn, say are illegal modifications to their rent-stabilized apartments. 

A dozen families were forced to temporarily move out of their apartments last year because the city deemed the buildings unsafe after they racked up nearly 200 violations. But in the months since, the families are learning that their homes are being transformed — a growing practice that threatens to displace long-time tenants, their lawyers say.


Thursday, January 5, 2023

Almost 65K vacant rent-stabilized apartments, DHCR reports

https://www.crainsnewyork.com/real-estate/median-rent-new-york-stabilized-apartments-roughly-1500-report-says

Crain's New York Business

65K vacant rent-stabilized apartments 'above the historical norm,' report says

Friday, December 23, 2022

116,000 rent-stabilized units have vanished since 2019

 https://therealdeal.com/2022/12/23/how-did-116000-rent-stabilized-units-vanish/

How did 116,000 rent-stabilized units vanish?

Deregulation severely limited by 2019 law, but may have happened anyway

New York /
December 23, 2022 10:17 AM

EXCERPT: 

There were 858,000 rent-regulated units registered with the state’s Division of Housing and Community Renewal as of November, down from 974,000 when the seminal Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act was passed in 2019, The City reported.

The drop came despite the law being designed to prevent landlords from deregulating vacant apartments after rents reached $2,774 a month — a common occurrence previously.

“There’s no reasonable explanation for why that should be happening within the law,” Edward Josephson, an attorney with the Legal Aid Society, told the publication.

One possibility is that landlords stopped re-renting unprofitable units as they became vacant because the 2019 law forbid substantial rent increases to pay for renovations and also cut off paths to deregulation.

....Witnick [Real Estate] declined to comment for the story. Across the landlord’s 36 Brooklyn and Manhattan buildings, 226 rent stabilized units — about 40% of its portfolio — have been deregulated since 2007, the publication noted.

....

Taking all those possibilities into consideration, however, still leaves tens of thousands of units missing since 2019. It may be that landlords simply aren’t reporting rent-regulated units. The City noted that landlords can register rent-stabilized apartments years late. But that was also true before the 2019 law passed.


Friday, November 18, 2022

Warehousing NOT caused by 2019 law - CityLimits article

 CityLimits

Empty Rent-Stabilized units in NYC Decreased This Year, as 'Warehousing' Debate Rages.

The latest vacancy data now mirrors pre-COVID figures following a "pandemic-height outlier," according to New York State's affordable housing agency. The number of empty apartments also matches the vacancy rate prior to landmark 2019 tenant protections that landlords blamed for the spike in empty units last year. 

by David Brand, published November 17, 2022.

EXCERPT: "With hundreds of thousands of low-income New Yorkers in need of an affordable home, even one warehoused unit is one too many,” said [Larry] Wood, of Goddard Riverside. 

Click on "Read More" for additional excerpts.

Tuesday, November 15, 2022

Tenants Rally on Proposed HPD Regulations

 

On November 15th, our Coalition joined Housing Justice for All, Make the Road NY, Met Council on Housing, the Cooper Square Committee, Tenants Taking Control and other groups on the steps of the US Customs House.  This was just before the Dept. of Housing and Community Development hearing on its proposed regulations to implement the 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act. The Coalition submitted testimony, as did several tenant leaders, including the Park West Village Tenant Association's president Pat Loftman, calling for the end of warehousing and Frankensteining, two loopholes that have severely affected affordable housing in New York City. 

A proposed regulation on "first rent" would end Frankensteining as we know it. The regulation would set the first rent of a newly-configured apartment by combining the previous legal rents, and adding any applicable "individual apartment improvement" increases (limited to $85 rent increase) and Rent Guidelines Board increases.  Where a rent stabilized unit is combined with non-apartment space (such as hallway), the rent would change by the same percentage as the square footage of the apartment. 

Under the current lack of regulations:  

RS unit "6A" rent of $800  + market-rate unit 7A's rent of $5000  → new rent is whatever market will bear (such as $9000!)  It's not even clear if the new unit is rent stabilized. 

Under proposed regulation:

RS unit 6A's rent of $800 + market-rate unit 7A's rent of $5000  → new rent is $5800 (plus about $85).   

That would discourage landlords from warehousing RS apartments so they could combine them at an enormous rent. 

We'll be at the Annual West Side Tenant Conference. Join us!

  Stop by our table this year's West Side Tenants Conference.